CHAPTER 10 - ASIAN CONSCIOUSNESS | MALAYA : Communist or Free?



[122]
‘It is no use treating the Asiatics, who are mostly illiterate, as one would treat Europeans’—Lord Jeffreys, in debate on Malaya in the House of Lords, 10 March, 1954.

The birth of an ‘Asian consciousness’ may prove to be the most significant happening of the twentieth century. During the World War II the Japanese exploited it to the utmost, endeavouring to appropriate to themselves the role of the Leaders of Asia. They failed, and in doing so revealed that they were interested, not in Asia, but exclusively in Japan, and thus unwittingly did the world a good service by demonstrating that Asian countries cannot count on other Asian countries being their comrades merely on the strength of the accident that they both inhabit the same continent. Nevertheless, since the war Asian consciousness has grown steadily, mainly because Western interests are still paramount in Asia and the West still aspires to a dominating role. This Asian consciousness cannot be likened to a sense of nationalism—it is too vague and unlocalized for that—it is in essence an ‘anti’ feeling born from a common resentment of the West.

To neutralize this sentiment is the most difficult of all tasks confronting an administrator in a territory that is still ‘colonial’, especially as it manifests itself so often in irrational and unpredictable forms. For example, it was widely said, and the statement is still often repeated, that the Americans dropped the atom bomb on Japan in 1945 because Japan is an Asian country, whereas they would not have dropped it on Europe (ignoring the fact that the bomb was not developed until after Germany’s surrender) , and in 1953 President Eisenhower’s policy of training Asian troops to take over where possible from European troops in Korea was represented as a cynical attempt to ‘ use Asians to fight Asians’.

There occurred between December and the middle of 1953 two incidents which, though unforeseeable, had the makings of

ASIAN CONSCIOUSNESS | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[123]
grave and lasting misunderstanding between the people of Malaya and the British. The first was the Hertogh case, and the second the case of Lee Meng.

The Hertogh Riots

Sixteen people were killed and 159 injured and business brought to a temporary standstill during the serious riots which took place in Singapore in December, 1950, as a result of the Hertogh case.

Maria Hertogh, a Dutch girl aged thirteen in 1950, was placed by her parents in the care of a Malay woman (who was her foster-mother) when the Japanese invaded Java in 1942. The parents were, on their release from internment, unable to trace the child, who was, however, found in the first half of 1950 living in Trengganu with her foster-mother. She spoke only Malay and had been brought up as a Muslim. The parents now took action for the return of the child. A court order was made for her return to her parents, but this was set aside in July. A committee was formed in Holland which requested the Netherlands Government to intervene. In consequence of this a summons was filed in the Singapore High Court and an order issued forbidding the girl’s removal from the precincts of the Court. During the hearing of the appeal she was married to a Malay, but the marriage was later held invalid by the Court. Since the marriage had been arranged during the girl’s residence in the Po Leung Kuk (a Government home for girls), she was now removed to a Roman Catholic convent for safe custody.

On 11 December the Appeal Court had adjourned for twenty-four hours the appeal for a stay of execution in the case when the rioting broke out and continued the following day. The girl in the meantime left by air for Holland.

Public opinion was shocked and the press severely criticized the Government and police for their slowness in meeting a serious crisis. The apparent apathy of the Malay police, who in many cases did not oppose the rioters and merely looked on while their own patrol cars were burned and while Chinese, Eurasians and Europeans were set upon and beaten, was the subject of caustic comment both in the press and the Legislative Council. The Government was blamed for offending Muslim feeling by accommodating Maria Hertogh in a convent during the hearing of the case and for making no use of the Mohammedan Advisory

ASIAN CONSCIOUSNESS | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[124]
Board. Speakers in the Legislative Council said that the courts had been brought into unparalleled contempt and that the riots might retard the attainment of self-government by Singapore by at least ten years. The Government promised a Commission of Enquiry and, pending its formation, invited Mr. D. W. Macintosh, Commissioner of Police, Hong Kong, to visit Singapore to make recommendations which could be put into force immediately. When the rioting ceased, the police arrested a large number of persons, including the president of the Singapore Muslim League.1

Mr. Macintosh arrived by air on 22 December, 1950, and, having made his report, several of his recommendations were immediately implemented. Steps were taken to strengthen the Gurkha contingent (481 recruits were hoped for but only 185 were obtained). Members of the Mohammedan Advisory Board visited the police rank and file to dispel any illusion that there was conflict between their duty as Muslims and their duty as members of the police force. This was the more essential, since the ground-swell of Muslim discontent continued for some time after Maria Hertogh had left the Colony, and the agitation was in some cases so extreme that a Malay newspaper was closed down under the Emergency Regulations.

The Commission of Enquiry appointed by the Governor arrived in the Colony on 10 February, began work on 15th, and signed its report on 17 May.2 The Commission found that the basic cause of the riots was the intense feeling aroused by the Hertogh case among the Muslim population of Singapore, aggravated by the girl’s presence in a Roman Catholic convent and exploited by the unscrupulous campaign of the Nadra Action Committee. The Commission accepted the fact that the police did not expect an outbreak of violence on 11 December, but considered that there had been a faulty appreciation of the likelihood of danger before the 11th, and that the Special Branch ought to have realized that there was a great possibility of serious trouble arising. The Commission found no evidence of Communist

1 It is convenient to mention here the arrest of Mr. John Eber on 8 January. He had been appointed to represent, ‘in forma pauperis’, Inche Adabi, the husband of Maria Hertogh, but he was in no way connected with the riots. He was kept in a prison for over two years without any charge being preferred against him, and the reason for his arrest and imprisonment remains today a mystery.
2 The Leach Report on the Singapore Riots, Singapore, August, 1951.

ASIAN CONSCIOUSNESS | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[125]
inspiration behind the riots and no acceptable testimony of any organization directing the rioters. The defection of the Malay police was attributed to the belief that the court proceedings were an attack on their religion and that Maria Hertogh was being forcibly converted to Christianity. But the Commission considered that their failure should not be given a significance beyond the specific situation in which it occurred. They possessed sterling qualities and were capable of fulfilling their duty in an emergency, provided that they were contented and properly led.

The Lee Meng Case

Lee Meng (alias Lee Teng-tai), a Chinese woman of twenty-four, was arrested in 1952 for being in possession of a hand-grenade. She was not in possession of the grenade at the time of her arrest, but the evidence of her possession of the grenade at a relevant time was given by a number of surrendered ex-Communist bandits. The assessor system in force in Perak where she was arrested provided for her trial by a European judge assisted by two assessors. The law said that in any trial on a charge punishable by death the judge should be assisted by two assessors. Three or four leading citizens were instructed to attend the court on the day of the trial and the judge chose two of them to assist him. Neither the prisoner nor the prosecution could challenge or object to any of the assessors chosen. One provision read, ‘When the accused, or any of the accused, is of European nationality, the assessors shall also be of European nationality.’ The usual practice was for one assessor to be of the ‘ nationality ’ (race) of the accused, the other being of some other ‘nationality’. This was to ensure that at least one of the assessors should know the language of the accused. Under the jury system which obtained in Singapore, Penang and Malacca the accused might object to four of the seven jurymen chosen by ballot without giving reasons. In the case of a jury, even if the judge disagreed with its unanimous decision, he must respect it. (This was what had happened in a recent trial in Malacca. The judge said that he could not see how a jury could have found the prisoner not guilty, but the man was acquitted nevertheless.) If the members of a jury disagreed among themselves there must be a 5-2 majority, one way or other, for a verdict to be returned. The important thing was that if a person were convicted by a 5-2 majority

ASIAN CONSCIOUSNESS | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[126]
he knew that five different people had found him guilty. Under the assessor system, the judge had to agree with only one other person in order to convict and sentence a prisoner to death.1

In Lee Meng’s first trial the two assessors were Asians, who found her Not Guilty. The judge disagreed and ordered a retrial. This time one of the assessors was a European and the other an Asian. The Asian assessor found her Not Guilty, but the European assessor found her Guilty, and, the judge agreeing with the latter, she was found Guilty and condemned to death by a majority of two to one. Application for leave to appeal to the Privy Council was refused on the ground that such an appeal could be only on a point of law, not one of fact. A petition for clemency was then signed by a number of British Members of Parliament and addressed to the Sultan of Perak, who had the power of reprieve. On 9 March the Sultan, on the advice of his Executive Council, commuted the sentence into one of penal servitude for life.

Lee Meng was alleged to be a senior member of the Communist Party. Before the Emergency she had been a teacher in a Chinese school. When she was sentenced to death the Hungarian Government offered to exchange for her Mr. Edgar Sanders, a British subject imprisoned in Budapest for espionage, but this offer was refused by the British Government.

An important feature of the Lee Meng case was that in a petition to the Sultan of Perak for Lee Meng’s reprieve it was alleged that if Asians had had the same right as Europeans— the right to trial by members of their own community—Lee Meng would not have been convicted. Commenting on this, the Singapore correspondent of The Times said,2 ‘This unhappy statement is the first to suggest that Malayans believe that communal prejudice was shown by an assessor.’ What the Straits Times3 described as ‘one of the more malicious publicity twists’ given to the case was the suggestion that it was necessary to organize the petition for Lee Meng’s reprieve in London, since the first move could not have been made in Malaya owing to the Emergency Regulations. No Asians would have dared to have signed it for fear of being taken for Communist sympathizers. This was a suspicion endorsed by Lee Meng’s solicitors.

One outcome of the case was a Government enquiry which was

1 ‘Lee Meng and the trial system’ by Patrick Keith, Straits Times, 25 February 1953.
2 2 February, 1953.
3 22 February, 1953.

ASIAN CONSCIOUSNESS | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[127]
expected to lead to the abolition of the assessor system, but, surprisingly, the committee of enquiry recommended—not only that there should be no jury, but that in future the judge should not be bound by the opinion of the assessors!

‘I’ll be judge, I’ll be jury, said cunning old Fury!’

The Back-pay Controversy1

When the Japanese occupied Malaya they interned all Europeans as enemy aliens. Non-European Government servants, generally speaking, remained at liberty. Many of the latter worked for the Japanese throughout the war, obtaining considerable favours and consideration by reason of their official status. Others were unable or unwilling to do so, and some were killed or suffered hardships quite as severe as internment. At the end of the war no action was taken against those who had not actively persecuted their fellow-Malayans and they were taken back into Government service and given some months pay for rehabilitation. The question of pay created a thorny problem. The Colonial Office obviously could not allow Government servants who were taken prisoner while serving in the forces or who had remained at their posts and had been interned for that reason, to fare worse than Government servants who had not been interned. But equally it could not impose on Great Britain the cost of paying the whole salary bill over nearly four years of an administration which had, in fact, continued to work for the enemy. Says Professor Silcock:

The solution actually achieved was extravagant, and, by common consent, unjust. It was based on alleged non-discrimination; full pay to those interned, and to those not interned the full difference between what the Japanese paid and their normal salary. As a result, the resources of Malaya were charged with the full payments to Europeans, which, however reasonable in themselves, were necessitated by general Colonial policy rather than by any specifically Malayan interest. . . . Nevertheless, there can be little doubt that a better solution was not possible without abandoning the myth of non-discrimination and facing frankly the fact that Europeans engaged in Great Britain are, in fact, if not in form, working for Great Britain through the machinery of local

1 See T. H. Silcock: Dilemma in Malaya, pp. 36 seq.

ASIAN CONSCIOUSNESS | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[128]
Colonial Governments, and this will continue so long as the Colonial system remains.

The above incidents or cases are only a few of a considerable number available for selection involving Asian-European feeling since the end of the Japanese War. This is the kind of thing that calls for great tact and understanding. In his time Lord Mountbatten showed himself adept at pouring oil on troubled waters, and for years Mr. MacDonald had been at hand with liberal supplies of healing unguent to apply to any new interracial wound. But neither tact nor balm will suffice for a cure which can come only from a true equality in a state of independence.

The 'Rat' Incident

Though ostensibly not an interracial matter, the incident (referred to again on pp. 241-2) in which General Templer called a Malay journalist and member of the Federal Legislative Council, Che Abdul Aziz bin Ishak, ‘a rat, and a rotten journalist whose name stinks in South-East Asia’, impinged harshly on Asian consciousness. Most articulate Malayans, and Malays in particular, interpreted this as racial superiority in the guise of a coercive paternalism unexcused by the bonds of affection of a true-blood relationship. Utusan Melayu (Aziz’s newspaper), in an article, took to task writers in the Straits Times who were quick to resent what they regarded as Aziz’s frank and perfectly legitimate account of the Coronation ceremony but who would not dream of rebuking a member of the ‘upper class’ (i.e. a European) for insulting behaviour. This was the undercurrent of feeling in much of the widespread protests against the General’s action, and the incident marked a chapter in British-Malay relations still unfortunately unclosed.

A careful examination of the offending article reveals that it was in no sense disloyal. It paid respectful tribute to Her Majesty’s fortitude and bearing throughout the long and exhausting ceremony, but made play with a few anomalies that would be apparent to a detached onlooker, and with the freedom of a reporter wishing to make his report a graphic one the writer made reference to one or two small anticlimaxes that are bound to occur even in a highly rehearsed ceremony and which relieve tension without injuring the solemnity. The article was indeed

ASIAN CONSCIOUSNESS | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[129]
far more respectful in tone than many articles on the Coronation that appeared in the British popular press.1

'Jungle Green’

This book, by Major (later Lieutenant-Colonel) Arthur Campbell of the Suffolk Regiment, enjoyed an instantaneous success when it was published in England in June, 1953. It was a record (somewhat synthetic) of the heroism and sacrifice of the British National Servicemen in the jungle, and in this aspect it was well calculated to stimulate British fighting morale and to stir the imagination of the people of Britain. It had, unfortunately, another aspect in that its tone was undeniably ‘anti-Chinese’, and no one could read it without receiving the impression that the Malayan Chinese as a community were the real ‘enemy’. Here are some quotations from it:

On p. 33 the author remarks, ‘ I did not trust the man. To begin with, he was a Chinaman. They were all two-faced beggars, sitting on the fence, waiting to see who was going to get the upper hand.’ On p. 93 a British soldier is quoted as saying, ‘I’ll admit it’s not our country, but all these niggers that live here look to us to see that the place is decently run. You may say that we have got ourselves into it—well, so we have, but now we’re in it we’ve got to send those Chinks back to where they came from.’ ‘ The usual nauseating smell of a Chinese house greeted us as we opened the door’ (p. 170). (It might be remarked that the smell of poverty is even more nauseating in some parts of London or Glasgow.) ‘Yellow’ is used as a term of opprobrium, and the bandits have ‘ beady eyes ’ or a ‘ meagre brain’. They are referred to as the ‘Antichrist of the jungle’.

The important fact, however, is that on the dust-cover of the book General Templer is quoted as saying, ‘This book is authentic’—an endorsement which makes the book of the first political significance.

The reaction of the Malayan Chinese Association to the book is conveyed in a press release from headquarters of 1 September, which runs as follows:

In Jungle Green, a book by Major Arthur Campbell on the war against the terrorists in Malaya, the Chinese are described

1 Aziz’s article, incidentally, was vastly more respectful to the Sovereign than was the account by the ultra-loyal Macaulay of the Coronation of William IV. See Sir G. O. Trevelyan, The Life and Letters of Lord Macaulay.

ASIAN CONSCIOUSNESS | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[130]
as ‘Chinks’, ‘Bastard Chinese’, and ‘two-faced beggars’ sitting on the fence waiting to see who is going to get the upper hand in the Malayan emergency.

The Malayan Chinese Association calls upon every Chinese in the country to boycott the book. This is the best method of meeting the unfair and biased comments contained in the book.

This Association notes with regret, but unfortunately not surprise, that the authorities propose to purchase thousands of copies of the book for circulation among the members of the armed forces in Malaya.

It is a trifle difficult to reconcile this intention to spend public money to the ultimate benefit of an individual with the recent statement from a very high authority that the general policy of Her Majesty’s representative is not discriminatory against the Chinese.

The latest anti-Chinese outburst in Jungle Green should prove conclusively, if proof were needed, that the Chinese in this country are faced by many and powerful enemies.1

The sources of friction and misunderstanding, of which the above are only examples, would mostly disappear with a colonial regime, but the whole question of future European-Asian relationships is much more subtle and elusive. Science dismisses ‘race’ as it is generally understood as a myth, but it is a myth with most powerful influences on human behaviour. Group prejudices are most jealously adhered to by the more ‘instinctive’, less educated elements in a ‘race’, and will not be fundamentally corrected until the whole world outlook is emancipated from the will to govern others and a genuine internationalism prevails. Coleridge, Shelley, Sir William Jones, Schlegel, Schopenhauer, Edwin Arnold and a hundred others were deeply influenced by Hindu thought, but Sir Alfred Lyall in his British Dominion in India denied the existence of ’civilization’ in India except to the extent that it had been introduced by the British, and Kipling, as we know, made this his major theme. We need a new poet to sing the role of Britain in an age of radical change.2

1 Of thirty-one passages objected to by the MCA, the author and publishers later agreed to delete sixteen.
2 The reporting of happenings in Malaya is often a source of offence, especially to Malayan students in this country. For example, when a London daily reported the killing of two Europeans and a Malay police corporal with the headline, ‘Two Britons die in Malaya’.

MALAYA : Communist or Free? by Victor Purcell.
Published in 1954 by STANFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS

No comments:

Post a Comment