CHAPTER 02 - HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?



[32]
Among the influences that have moulded modern Malaya that of the British is by far the most important. British interest in the Malay Peninsula, which had lapsed after the successful Dutch opposition of the early seventeenth century, revived towards the end of the eighteenth. In 1786 the cession of the island of Penang was obtained by Francis Light from the Sultan of Kedah as a ‘ careening station ’ for ships disabled in the Bay of Bengal and as a place in which to grow spices to compete with the Dutch monopoly. A strip of the mainland (Province Wellesley) was added in 1800. Penang had a chequered career and was not a financial success, though a sudden and extravagant belief in its future led to its being promoted to be the Fourth Presidency of India in 1805. The effective history of the British in Malaya, however, begins with the foundation of Singapore by Sir Stamford Raffles in 1819. Situated at the narrow entrance to the Straits of Malacca, its strategic position was ideal, and, being at the conflux of several trade routes, its commercial possibilities were great. Moreover, Raffles’s free-trade policy attracted Asian traders, who flocked there in considerable

1The scope of this study does not provide for deep ‘historical roots’, but the following will serve as a pointer.

The aboriginals of the country (Negritos, Temiar, etc. etc., collectively known as ‘Sakai ’) still number about 35,000. The Malays proper arrived in Malaya in early times, but they were reinforced by a series of migrations from Indonesia which are still continuing. Hindu influences extended to Malaya early in the Christian era, and it was not until half-way through its career (c. 1400-1511) that the Malay kingdom of Malacca turned from Hinduism to Islam. The Portuguese occupied Malacca from 1511 to 1641, and the Dutch from 1641 to 1824 (though the control of that Settlement passed to the British during the wars with France). European influence extended over wide areas of the hinterland, but certain Malay States in succession (Johore, Acheen, etc.) extended their sway over their neighbours to form what have been somewhat grandiosely referred to as ‘empires’.

The history of Malaya, hitherto the preserve of civil servants and one or two wandering scholars, is now being systematically studied in the University of Malaya.

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[33]
numbers to enjoy this innovation under the protection of the British flag. Singapore, Penang and Malacca (obtained finally by the treaty with the Dutch of 1824) were joined to form the Straits Settlements. In spite of the piracy which was rife in these waters, the British Colony prospered, even though it remained a financial burden to the East India Company to the end of the latter’s existence (1858), since no effective taxation of the trade had been devised. In 1867 the Straits Settlements, having satisfied the British Government that they could in future pay their own way, were transferred from the control of the Government of India to the supervision of the Colonial Office.

Meanwhile the Malay States of the interior had fallen into a state of decay bordering on anarchy. Their population in the mid-nineteenth century did not exceed 400,000 (including the four Northern States) and was confined to the banks of rivers and the coastlines. There were no roads, no public buildings, schools, or courts of law, and the social system was strictly feudal. About 1850 the disorder was accentuated when the discovery of fresh tin deposits in Perak attracted Chinese miners from the tin mines of Selangor, Sungei Ujong and elsewhere in increasing numbers. These were soon in conflict with the Malay chiefs and among themselves, divided as they were into rival factions by their secret societies. The disorders continued for some years, but in spite of petitions from Chinese merchants in the Straits Settlements, whose interests were at stake, the British refused to accept any further territorial responsibilities. Finally, however, under the influence of the changed attitude of Britain towards colonial expansion (often dated from Disraeli’s Speech of 1872), this policy was reversed and it was announced, in 1873, that ‘Her Majesty’s Government found it incumbent to employ such influence as they possess with the native princes to rescue, if possible, these fertile and productive countries from the ruin which must befall them if the present disorders continue unchecked ’.

The Governor of the Straits Settlements, acting under this new policy, intervened in Perak, where there was a dispute in progress as to the succession to the throne, backing one of the claimants whom he recognized as Sultan. This Sultan (Abdullah) then signed a treaty whereby he agreed to accept a British Resident, whose advice ‘ should be asked for and acted upon in all questions other than those touching Malay religion and custom’. This formula was adopted in all subsequent treaties with the Rulers of

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[34]
the several Malay States, and is the basis of the Protectorate system which survives in the Federal Agreement for the constitution of 1948. Selangor was the next State after Perak to accept (indeed, ask for) a treaty, then Negri Sembilan (literally ‘Nine States’, which were persuaded to amalgamate under a common Ruler—a fact emphasizing the fragmentation of the Peninsula), then Pahang in 1888. These four States agreed to federation as the Federated Malay States from 1 January, 1896. Johore, the remaining Malay State at the extreme south, had previously been in treaty relations with Britain, but a definitive treaty was signed in 1914. The four northern States—Kedah, Perlis, Kelantan, and Trengganu—had been outside the British sphere and under the suzerainty of Siam, but in 1909 this suzerainty was transferred to the British Crown and separate treaties on the model of those previously made with the individual States of the Federated Malay States were signed between the Rulers and the Crown.

The British had hoped that the States outside the Federation would eventually join it, but for several reasons this did not come to pass. For one thing the unfederated States saw that the Federation had entailed a considerable loss of sovereignty to the four States composing it, and for another the Federation had had to bear the capital cost of undertakings such as the railways. Finally a decentralization scheme was put into operation in 1935 on the initiation of Sir Cecil Clementi (Governor from 1929 to 1934). By this, much of the previous autonomy was restored to the individual States of the Federation though the federal machinery was retained for reasons of convenience. Sir Cecil Clementi’s intention was that co-ordination should be brought about by the centralizing of advisory powers in Kuala Lumpur. But things did not turn out quite in this way, and the main effect of decentralization was to confirm the fragmentation of the Peninsula, an area the size of England without Wales, but with ten separate governments. Local patriotism was thus encouraged which was obstructive to the growth of a Malayan sentiment.

Before the British intervened in the affairs of the Peninsula the Malay States had been very fluid and uncertain in their extent. Except where there was a river or a coastline, the boundaries of the States were not demarcated and were vaguely indicated by a natural feature such as a range of hills. Now they were accurately surveyed, delimited and mapped. From this time henceforth

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[35]
there would be no ebb and flow of dynastic ambition. The existing situation was crystallized for ever by treaty and the crude correctives for discontent in a feudal society (court intrigue and assassination) were abolished. By the very nature of the agreements the Malay Sultanates became the instruments of British purpose even though the appearance of independent sovereignty was carefully preserved. When it suited the protecting power the succession was changed (as in the case of Johore and Selangor). However, the wealth of these weak and unstable principalities was vastly increased, and with it the pomp and circumstance attaching to the Rulers. The loss in their real power was compensated for by a kind of royal mystique, based no doubt on tradition but reinforced and adorned by British statecraft and research.

The feudal system of the Malay States was taken over as it stood. The adat (customary) law was preserved and codified, and the hereditary chiefs, sub-chiefs and penghulus (village headmen) were retained. But the real power was vested in the British Resident and his staff of civil servants. These in the first decades were Britons who started their careers as Junior Officers at the age of eighteen or nineteen, and later, when the Civil Service system was extended to the Malay States from the Straits Settlements, young men of twenty-three to twenty-four with a university background replaced them. Then in the ’twenties a policy was introduced of replacing European District Officers by Malays, and by the eve of World War II this process was practically complete. The Malay recruits to the Civil Service were all from the aristocracy, most of whom were trained at the Malay College at Kuala Kangsar, which thus became a sort of ‘ Eton of Malaya’. However, the Malay element accounted for no more than a tenth of the entire Malayan Civil Service (a small corps d'ilite of the ‘Heaven Born’ which never numbered more than 250), and was confined to the Malay States. The British Resident (or British Adviser, as he was termed in the unfederated States except Johore, where he was a General Adviser) reigned supreme over the local oligarchy, and finance and land were entirely in his hands. The Resident or Adviser was subject, of course, to the Ruler in Council and above that to his superiors, the Chief Secretary (until this post was abolished in 1935), and the High Commissioner, which appointment was held ex officio by the Governor of the Straits Settlements. The entire administration was in 1939

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[36]
virtually in the hands of the British acting through their Residents or Advisers. The powers reverted to the Ruler had mainly a prestige value, though Sultans of strong character could assert themselves within well-defined limits. The system undoubtedly had much to recommend it, for, while the obstruction to the will of the British was small, the self-respect of the Malays was maintained. Its weakness was the ossification of native institutions which inevitably set in and the erection within the country of artificial barricades.

The effect of the treaties was that Malaya was soon pacified and open for development in what was to be the age of colonial expansion and imperialism. Nevertheless progress in that direction was slow at first. Roads and railways were built, but the capital needed for development was not immediately forthcoming owing to the absence of an adequate labour force. The Malays were peasant cultivators who worked hard on their holdings planted with padi, coconuts, and fruit, but were not available in any large numbers for estate cultivation. The problem of labour supply was eventually solved by obtaining Tamils from South India for the estates while Chinese came in sufficient numbers to work the tin mines and also supplied the higher-paid labour for the opening up of new estates. To begin with, cultivation was of sugar and coffee, but the rubber industry was destined to supersede the existing cultivation to a great extent and to provide Malaya with its greatest single source of revenue. This industry was purely a British creation. Rubber seeds were brought from Brazil in the eighteen-seventies and the first trees reached Malaya via Kew and Ceylon. The industry first became profitable about 1906. There were successive booms and slumps (rubber fetched 12s. 9d. a pound in 1910 and only a trifle over 2d. a pound in 1931), and Malaya suffered from undue dependency on one main crop, but at the same time the revenues for the development of Malaya would not have been available without the income from this source and from tin mining, which was greatly expanded in the present century.1

The effect of this development was entirely to change the face of Malaya and to increase its population several-fold, and incidentally to create a political problem of the first order through the rivalry of numerically equal communities, the Malays

1 ‘The Malayan soil and climate are on an average inferior to those of surrounding countries except possibly Borneo. Its soil is rapidly exhausted and quickly erodes; its climate is on the damp and cloudy side, operating against high yields and seasonal crops.’ E. H. G. Dobby. Agricultural Questions of Malaya (Oxford University Press, 1949), p. 38.

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[37]
and the Chinese. A road system comparing favourably with that in any part of the world was built; railways were opened up along the west coast from Singapore to Siam, with branches to the ports and later an east coast-line was added. The revenue was applied to public works, irrigation schemes, and education and welfare (though critics of the system have argued that undertakings in aid of capital enterprise came first and education and welfare last).

Immigrants, especially from China, flocked in to share the growing prosperity, and, by their labours, to add to it. The total population of British Malaya (less the four northern States and Johore at that time) was in 1891 only 831,000 (409,000 in the Straits Settlements and 422,000 in the Federated Malay States. In 1911 (after the four northern States had been added in 1909 and including Johore) the total was 2,654,000; in 1921,3,327,000; in 1931, 4,348,000; in 1947, 5,849,000; and mid-1951, 6,379,000 (Federation, 5,337,000; Singapore, 1,042,000). But more striking even than the increase in the population had been the change in its racial composition. In 1921 the Malays had accounted for 48.8 per cent of the total, the Chinese 35.2 per cent, and the Indians 14.2 per cent; in 1931 37.8 per cent were Malays and 6.6 Other Malaysians (the immigrants of Malay race being separately enumerated for the first time), 39.2 Chinese, and 14.3 Indians; in 1947, 38.2 per cent Malays and 5.29 per cent Other Malaysians, 44.7 per cent Chinese, and 10.25 per cent Indians. This meant that the Chinese were by 1947 the most numerous single group in the Federation of Malaya and Singapore together, but in the Federation the Malays were still in a majority—Malays, 2,162,000; Other Malaysians, 266,000; total, 2,428,000; together 49.46 per cent of the total, while the Chinese numbered 1,885,000 or 38.4 per cent of the total. In Singapore in 1947 the Chinese accounted for 77.61 per cent of the total population (i.e. 730,000 out of 941,000).

This very rapid increase in the Chinese population was bound to be significant to the politics of Malaya. These immigrants were more active and enterprising than the natives of the country, and in addition to supplying most of the artisans, they largely monopolized the petty trading, though the Indians, too, had a share of this. In entrepreneur undertakings, however, they remained second to the Europeans.1 The economic pressure of the

1 After 1921 the increased use of modem equipment (dredges) meant that the Europeans changed places with the Chinese in the tin industry, owning

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[38]
Chinese on the agrarian Malays was recognized from 1913 onwards by the creation of large Malay land reservations in which the land could not be alienated to non-Malays. But increasing suspicion of Chinese economic encroachment sometimes amounted to open resentment. However, the outward relationship between the communities was good and there were no communal disturbances before the Japanese occupation. The Indians played a more passive role in Malayan affairs, being composed mainly of rubber estate workers recruited from the Madras Presidency (though the recruiting system was frowned upon by the Government of India, and eventually in 1938 the emigration of Indian labour was stopped).

While immigration was causing a change amounting to a silent revolution, Malaya still remained theoretically a ‘Malay country’. The paternalistic British administration gave the Malays preference for Government appointments (even so, the Chinese filled most of the clerkships and the Jaffna Tamils practically monopolized the lower administration of the railways) and provided them with free primary education. While an acquaintance with the Malay language was considered as an indispensable requirement for a European civil servant, the study of the Chinese and the Indian languages was relegated to specialists who together accounted for less than 20 per cent of the total Malayan Civil Service. The royal road to advancement was by the way of the ‘Ulu’ (the ‘interior’, where the ‘real Malaya’ was supposed to exist as distinguished from the modern excrescences of immigration and industry).

There was Chinese and Indian representation on the various councils, though its influence was very restricted. In the Federal and Legislative (Straits Settlements) Councils there was an official majority at the disposal of the Governor if emergency required. But British power was exercised with discretion and in a spirit of compromise, and members of the Councils were canvassed before a measure was introduced into the legislature. If the opposition was very strong the measure was usually dropped (only on rare occasions was the official majority used—notably for the introduction of a Textile Quotas Bill in the ’thirties to check dumping by Japan, and after World War II for the reintroduction of income-tax, which was opposed by Europeans

about two-thirds of it to the Chinese one-third, whereas earlier in the century their positions were reversed.

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[39]
as well as Malayan unofficials). Since Malaya at this period was a glorified commercial undertaking rather than a ‘State’, the commercial interests of Mincing Lane and Leadenhall Street exercised continuous pressure on the Secretary of State for the Colonies (more often than not one of themselves), but, on the other hand, the Colonial Office was often able to exercise a restraining influence on the power of the unofficials in Malaya itself. There were as yet no signs of any democratic movement, though the germ of self-government might perhaps be detected in the municipalities of Singapore, Penang and Malacca, which had Asian majorities and whose decisions were subject only to the Governor’s veto.

It was commonly said that up to 1942 Malaya ‘had no politics’. This was largely true in the domestic sense, but it would be wrong to imagine that Malaya had remained immune from the ferment of nationalism and Communism which was going on in the rest of Asia. The Chinese of Malaya had early come under the influence of Chinese nationalism (Sun Yat-sen had been financed mainly by the Overseas Chinese, and in 1911 he had been warned by the Government to leave Penang, since the imperial China he was plotting against was a power in friendly relations with Britain). The rise of the spirit of nationalism was manifested by an outburst of zeal for education, and in the years succeeding World War I the China-born Malayan Chinese had opened schools by the score in which the doctrines of the Revolution were disseminated through the medium of Mandarin, the new ‘National Language’. The coming into power of the Kuomintang in 1926-7 and its successful drive to the north encouraged the growth of the Kuomintang in South-East Asia, and the Nationalist Government was not slow to exploit the situation by sending educational and other missions to Malaya and collecting funds there for the prosecution of their war against the Japanese. ‘China-born’ morale ebbed and flowed with the advances or setbacks of the Kuomintang in China and was very little affected by what was happening in Malaya itself. The aggression of the Japanese from 1931 onwards provoked outbursts of feeling among them which found an outlet in attempts to boycott Japanese goods.

Communism had appeared in Malaya first of all in the ’twenties, but was organized separately from the Kuomintang only after the latter had carried out its left-wing purge in 1927. To begin with, European agents were used, but this was soon

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[40]
recognized to be bad policy, and henceforth Asians, mostly Chinese, were employed. They worked through the Communist-controlled General Labour Union, through the Chinese schools, and latterly through the youth organizations such as the Anti-Enemy Backing-Up League. The appeal of Communism, however, was at that time limited and was off-set by the Kuomintang, and the latter probably caused more embarrassment to the Malayan authorities than the former up to the outbreak of the Japanese War.

These signs of political activity among the Chinese were bound to increase the apprehension the Malays felt regarding Chinese expansionist motives. And this apprehension was shared by a section among the Chinese themselves, broadly speaking the Malayan-born, or, more accurately, the English-educated, who, while remaining Chinese in sentiment, were yet unwilling that the Chinese community should become an imperium in imperio under the control of the Government of China. It seems probable that in the early ’thirties at least this feeling might have been exploited by a government policy encouraging the Malayan-born Chinese to associate themselves more closely with Malaya itself, by granting them privileges on an equality with the Malays, and by the rapid extension of free education in English. In this way they might have been decisively detached from the China-minded Kuomintang supporters. But the Governor of that time, Sir Cecil Clementi, was more concerned to check the power of the Chinese as a community than he was to attempt any fusing of the Malayan-born Chinese interests with those of the Malays, and he adhered strictly to the letter of the treaties. He refused, moreover, to recognize any free education except through the medium of Malay. It is, of course, debatable whether a scheme of National Schools could have succeeded even at that time in welding Malaya into a nation, but it is certain that the early ’thirties were more propitious for such an experiment than was the postwar period, when the attempt was made to force such a policy through under the Templer regime.

Malay reaction to Chinese political activity did not take the form of creating their own parties; they relied even more heavily on British protection to keep the Chinese at bay. There was indeed in the pre-war years a growth of the Pan-Islamic movement, stimulated by kathis from the Hadramaut, and there was some small response to the Egyptian bid to be the leader of Islam. But the movement did not have any noticeable effect on the

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[41]
Malays, who were inclined to be tolerant in their beliefs. It can be said that on the eve of the Japanese War the Malays were in a kind of moody apathy. Until the slump of 1930-2, the administration had taken no steps to control Chinese immigration and had done nothing effective to arrest the economic retreat of the Malays. It was therefore not altogether surprising if a considerable section of the Malays regarded the imminence of a Japanese invasion with no great disfavour. When the Japanese did come this feeling was accentuated. Here, at least, was a people who would adopt no laissez-faire attitude towards the Chinese but would keep them severely in their place. It was only when the Malays found that the Japanese had no aim except to sacrifice all non-Japanese (whom they regarded as their inferiors) to their war effort that Malay opinion swung against them.

The Japanese invasion changed the picture overnight. As has been explained in Chapter I, the fall of France left Malaya exposed to direct Japanese attack, and on 8 December, 1941, they landed at Kota Bharu. The history of the ten-weeks campaign in which they advanced five hundred miles over country that had been believed largely impassable and occupied Singapore has yet to be written, and much more than is at present known will be required to explain the rapidity of the Japanese advance and the ineffectiveness of the British opposition.

For over three and a half years Malaya was under the Japanese yoke, its trade ruined, its population reduced to semi-starvation, and submitted to the savage rule of the Kempeitai (Gestapo).

Directly after the fall of Singapore (15 February, 1942) the Japanese proceeded to round up all the Chinese Communists they could lay their hands on and to execute them without trial. Those who escaped joined their comrades in the interior and took refuge in the jungle of the highlands, where they formed a guerilla organization to resist the Japanese (the Malayan People’s Anti-Japanese Army, as it was later called) and (even more importantly) to fight for the establishment of a People’s Republic of Malaya. In May, 1943 two British officers from the South-East Asia Command landed from a submarine near Pangkor Island, and, making for the Cameron Highlands, they made contact with the MPAJA. Eventually in 1945 an agreement was made between the guerillas and Lord Mountbatten, whereby the former were to assist in the intended invasion of Malaya in return for arms, money and supplies (the objective of the Republic

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[42]
for Malaya was then temporarily dropped from the objectives of the Communists). In the event, the surrender of the Japanese in August, 1945, made the invasion unnecessary, and British troops landed in September to take the Japanese surrender and to liberate the country. In the meantime the MPAJA had emerged from the jungle and had assumed control of the countryside and the towns, and when the British Military Administration arrived to take over they yielded to them with very ill grace. However, the agreement between them and the Supreme Allied Commander was precariously maintained, and in December the MPAJA was disbanded, 5,800 arms being handed in and each man receiving $350 for his services. The Communists, working through the General Labour Union, now concentrated on the subversion of labour and initially with great success. On 27-30 January they were able to bring about an almost complete standstill in southern Malaya and Singapore. However, on 15 February, 1946, when they attempted to foment a general stoppage of work to celebrate the surrender of the British in February, 1942, they overreached themselves and their plan was a complete failure. After that they confined themselves to underground activity until they declared open war on the British in June, 1948, and the Emergency began.

Retrospect

Looking back, the pre-war years were a halcyon period. Malaya was virtually ruled by the Malayan Civil Service, a body of disinterested officials whose only aim and inducement was to do the best they could in their several offices. There were none of the checks or impediments of democratic government; there was no need to play up to the prejudice or ignorance of an electorate nor to sacrifice the public benefit to political expediency. This situation in some respects so nearly approached the ideal that the British might be pardoned for wishing to perpetuate it; they cannot, however, receive the same pardon for believing (if they did) that it would last forever. When the change began to come a number of the more conservative-minded officials refused to believe that the new forces were not temporary manifestations of evil and sedition, whereas to a more open-minded observer the developments might seem obvious and inevitable.

Long before the war with Japan Malayan society, politically speaking, was like a chemical solution approaching saturation.

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[43]
The surface was normally smooth and untroubled, though now and then an eddy might betray the working of forces unseen. The police and the Chinese Protectorate were fully occupied in keeping a check on the efforts of the Kuomintang to create an imperium in imperio, of the Communists to stir up labour trouble, and of youths organized into ‘Anti-Japanese-Backing-Up Societies’ to enforce a boycott against the Japanese by direct methods of violence and intimidation. The fear of Chinese economic encroachment felt by the Malays was manifested only at long intervals (as, for example, when it was suggested that Chinese should be encouraged to plant rice in the Malay States); otherwise it was scarcely perceptible. Race relations were outwardly harmonious. It needed the catalyst of the Japanese invasion to cause the solution to precipitate.

Such processes were in the nature of Asian history and quite beyond the control of the British in Malaya. However, if the destiny of the country was to become a self-governing State within the British Commonwealth, able to take its place with confidence in the new world, it is not difficult to see the respects in which British policy could be subjected to criticism. Two obvious faults were: first, the almost complete failure to teach the people to govern themselves; and, second, the turning of Malaya into a ‘plural society’.

The neglect of representative institutions arose from the snug convenience of the ‘protectorate system’, by which Malay society was in theory preserved while European enterprise had completely unrestricted play. Thus a feudal society was perpetuated and petrified at the same time through desuetude. Since in theory the Malay authoritarian institutions governed the country under British guidance, there was no need for any elective system. Thus popularly elected councils, federal, state, or local, were unknown, and Western local government was not introduced in the rural districts until 1953—sixty-eight years behind India and twenty or so behind the so-called ‘backward’ African colonies. Thus was Malaya deprived of the evolutionary steps towards democratic government.

The turning of Malaya into a plural society was in the interests of economic development, and without immigration on a large scale it is almost certain that Malaya would never have become the rich country she did, with revenues available for public works, education and social services. It is pointed out by critics, however, that the standard of living of the Malay ryat was not

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[44]
raised during the British period, but such criticism disregards the improvement in the conditions of life and labour by anti-malarial works, hospitals, irrigation, communications, etc., and, one might even add, by permitting the introduction of cheap Japanese bicycles, which revolutionized Malayan life (and, incidentally, assisted the growth of nationalism and sedition). The neglect lay, it seems, in not facilitating the absorption of the immigrants who had made Malaya their home for generations by treating them on the same level as the Malays, which might have been done without injury to the latter. But admittedly this statement raises arguments of a more controversial kind.

Colonial regimes are by their nature transitional. The measure of the success of a colonial power is surely the degree to which it prepares its colony or protectorate to pass into the next phase of existence with the minimum of friction and dislocation. The object of such peaceful succession would be to ensure that what was valuable in the colonial regime was retained and not lost or destroyed in the civil tumult. But it seems that, however carefully the colonial power may prepare the way for the future, the only way in which a nation may develop in the place of the colony is in opposition to the colonial power. Statesmanship lies in arresting that process at a point before it entails a complete breaking off into a hostile republic (the classic example is the United States) and ensuring that it retains a close relationship in equality with the colonial or metropolitan power when the breach finally comes (the classic examples are India and Ceylon).

If the history of the British colonial regime in Malaya should be written by Marxists it will undoubtedly be condemned (as the Dutch colonial system was condemned by Marx himself in Capital) as the heartless exploitation of a country and a people; if it is written by anti-imperialists of the Hobson School it will likewise be condemned as wrong ab initio and per se. Should a true national movement arise in Malaya it is bound to be in opposition to colonial rule, and Malayan history books used in the schools of an independent ‘ nationalist ’ Malaya will concentrate, no doubt, on the last stages of military dictatorship and rule by emergency regulation and will say nothing of the mild and beneficent Government of before World War II. It is only when in the distant future an Asian Gibbon arises that the world will see colonial Malaya in just perspective as an indispensable phase in the development of human resources.

MALAYA : Communist or Free? by Victor Purcell.
Published in 1954 by STANFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS

No comments:

Post a Comment