CHAPTER 04 - CONSTITUTIONAL EXPERIMENT | MALAYA : Communist or Free?



[52]
In 1880 Sir Frederick Weld, the Governor of the Straits Settlements, declared that ‘ nothing we have done so far has taught them (the people of the country) to govern themselves; we are merely teaching them to co-operate with us and govern under our guidance’. The same might have been written in 1941, sixty years afterwards, with almost the same effective truth. The Federal and Legislative Councils, with their official majorities and their unofficials cither appointed directly by the Governor or High Commissioner or by him on the recommendation of somebody with special interests (such as a Chamber of Commerce), could scarcely be regarded as forcing houses of democratic government, while the municipalities with their Asian majorities were still confined to the Straits Settlements (in the Malay States local government was carried on by Town or Sanitary Boards composed mainly of officials). But the prospect of recovering Malaya compelled the British Government, and, in particular, the Colonial Office, to think carefully what sort of regime should be established when Malaya was liberated from the Japanese.

The decision arrived at was that the time was opportune for the revision of the pre-war constitution with its absurd fragmentation of the country, and at the same time for creating an equality of citizenship for all races domiciled in Malaya as a prerequisite for advance towards democratic, responsible government. A White Paper, published on 22 January, 1946, set out the Government’s proposals.1 The British Crown (the Paper said) must provide the common link which would draw together the communities of Malaya and promote a sense of common interest and the development of common institutions. To secure jurisdiction for His Majesty in the Malay States, Sir Harold MacMichael had concluded an agreement with each of the Malay Rulers, which, supplementing the existing treaties, granted jurisdiction in each

1 Malayan Union and Singapore, Cmd. 6724/1946.

CONSTITUTIONAL EXPERIMENT | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[53]
State to His Majesty. The British Government proposed to constitute Singapore as a separate Colony; the remainder of the country would be amalgamated as the Malayan Union. There would be a central authority for the Union consisting of a Governor with an Executive and a Legislative Council. Subsidiary powers of administration and legislation would be exercised by a local council for each State and Settlement. But (the paper went on), while it is the intention that the constitution shall be broad-based and representative, the final composition of these councils would not be decided until there had been consultation with local opinion. In view of the ‘special position of the Malay Rulers as traditional and spiritual leaders of the Malay people’, it was intended that the Ruler in each State should preside over a Malay Advisory Council which should have jurisdiction over matters affecting the Mohammedan religion but might also advise the Ruler on any other matters at the request of the Resident Commissioner acting with Government approval. On matters of Mohammedan religion, excepting the collecting of tithes and taxes, each Ruler, with the help of his Council, would have legislative powers within his State.

The White Paper went on to lay down the principles for the creation of a Malayan Union Citizenship. The policy of His Majesty’s Government was to promote a broad-based citizenship which would include, without discrimination of race or creed, all who could establish a claim, by reason of birth or a suitable period of residence, to belong to the country.

Soon after the announcement of the British Government’s policy in October, 1945, there had been signs that this policy did not meet with the approval of a number of ex-Malayan civil servants. On 29 October Sir Frank Swettenham, a former Governor of the Straits Settlements, enquired in The Times'. ‘Who has asked for these changes and a Malay Union? Certainly it is not the Malays.’ There was, however, no outward indication of opposition in Malaya until after the publication of the White Paper (Cmd. 6724) in January, but there was then a demonstration of Malays in Kedah, said to be 50,000 strong, carrying banners denouncing the recent agreements. In January, 1946, Dato Onn bin Jaafar had organized the Malay Peninsula Movement, and early in March he founded the United Malays National Organization (UMNO), which he claimed was supported by 70-80 per cent of the Malay population. Then in The Times of

CONSTITUTIONAL EXPERIMENT | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[54]
16 April there appeared a letter signed by seventeen prominent ex-MCS officers, including two-ex-Governors, characterizing the MacMichael agreement as ‘an instrument for annexation’, but adding that they had good reason to believe that the Rulers would agree to a federation. There is little doubt that this letter powerfully encouraged opposition to the infant Union which had come into being on 1 April. In May two members of Parliament visited Malaya, where they were greeted by widespread mass demonstrations of Malays which were coupled with demands for the repeal of the Union and the ‘MacMichael treaties’.

During this time the Chinese were unaccountably inactive and made no attempt to defend the Union which was so much to their advantage (an omission for which the Chinese leaders have since expressed regret), and in default of encouragement from this quarter the British Government decided to yield to the pressure of the Malays and their European supporters. On 25 July a Working Committee consisting of representatives of the Malayan Union Government, of the Rulers and of UMNO was appointed to submit agreed views, if possible, as the basis for a possible alternative constitution (there were no Malayan communities except the Malays represented on the committee). After working from August to November, 1946, the Working Committee embodied its proposals in a draft of a proposed Federation agreement and a model State agreement.1

The British Government had stated that it would not come to a final decision until all the interested communities in Malaya had been given a full' and free opportunity of expressing their views. Accordingly, in December, the Malayan Union had appointed a Consultative Committee composed mainly of influential representatives of the non-Malay communities. The committee was instructed to hold meetings throughout the Peninsula and to receive oral and written representation. The report of the Consultative Committee2 stated that whereas the Working Committee had recommended a Council of 45 members, in addition to the High Commissioner as President, and allotted the seats in such a manner that there would be a large Malay majority, they were of the opinion that the size of the Council should be increased to 52 members and that of these scats 29

1 Constitutional Proposals for Malaya . . Kuala Lumpur, 1947.
2Report of the Consultative Committee, Kuala Lumpur, 1947.

CONSTITUTIONAL EXPERIMENT | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[55]
should go to the Malays and 29 to the other communities, 3 remaining unallocated. As regards citizenship, the committee recommended that Federal Citizens should comprise: (a) subjects of the Sultan, (b) British subjects or any person born in the Malay States who was permanently resident in either of the Settlements or a Malay State, (c) any person whose father was a Federal Citizen.

The final decision of the British Government was embodied in the Federation of Malaya Agreement, 1948.1 To meet the recommendations of the Consultative Committee it had been decided to extend the total membership of the Legislative Council, allotting 50 unofficial seats, which would be likely to give the Malays 22 seats and the Chinese 14; the Indians would have 5, the Europeans 7, the Ceylonese 1, and the Eurasians 1. While the 9 Presidents of the State Councils would be Malays, the 2 representatives of the Settlement Councils might be from any community. The actual composition of the Council at mid-1952 was 75 members, in addition to the High Commissioner, of whom 34 were Malays and 14 Chinese. Later a Speaker (a Malay) was appointed to preside over the Council.

The agreement created a Federal Citizenship (not a Nationality) which could be acquired by operation of law or by application. Those automatically Federal Citizens comprised: (a) subjects of the Ruler of any State, (b) British subjects permanently resident in the Federation, (c) British subjects whose father was either born within the territories now comprised in the Federation or was at the birth of the British subject in question permanently settled in such territories, (d) any person born in the said territories who ‘habitually speaks the Malay language and conforms to Malay custom (e) any other person both of whose parents were born in the said territories and who were permanently resident at the time of such birth, and (f) any person whose father was, at the date of his birth, a Federal Citizen.2

The definition of ‘Subject of the Ruler’ was extended by the State Enactments of 1952, as is described below.

1 The Federation of Malay Agreement 1948, reprinted January, 1952, Kuala Lumpur.
*‘Subject of the Ruler’ for the purpose of (a) was defined as one who (i) belongs to an aboriginal tribe resident in the State, or (ii) is a Malay born in that State, or born outside of a father who was at the time of his birth a subject of the Ruler, or (iii) is naturalised as such. ‘Malay* is defined as any person who: (i) habitually speaks the Malay language and (ii) professes the Muslim religion, and (iii) conforms to Malay custom.

CONSTITUTIONAL EXPERIMENT | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[56]
Federal Citizenship could also be conferred by a grant of a certificate from the High Commissioner to anyone who satisfied him that he was born in the territories comprised in the Federation and had resided in one or more of them for eight out of the twelve preceding years or fifteen out of the twenty preceding years and who was of good character, had an adequate knowledge of the Malay or English language, and made a Declaration of Permanent Settlement, and was willing, if his application was approved, to take the Citizenship Oath.

Federal Citizenship could be lost by continued absence from the Federation or by doing an act which the High Commissioner was satisfied was incompatible with loyalty to the Federation.

It will be seen that whereas a Malay born in a Malay State was automatically a Federal Citizen, a Chinese was so born only if both his parents had been born within the Federation. In June, 1949, it was estimated that out of 1,952,682 Chinese resident in the Federation only 375,000 were Federal Citizens by operation of law.1

The reaction of the Chinese to the new constitution was strongly hostile. A ‘hartal’, or stoppage of work, was sponsored by the Pan-Malayan Council of Joint Action (with Mr. Tan Cheng-lock as President; he had undoubtedly adopted the word ‘ hartal ’ from his experience when he was resident in India during the Japanese occupation of Malaya), the Associated Chinese Chambers of Commerce, the Malayan Trade Unions, and the Malayan Communist Party, as a protest against the proposals for the Federation. On 20 October, 1947, virtually all business and transport were at a standstill. Another protest took the form of boycotting the new Singapore Legislative Council elections in 1947 and in consequence only about 20,000 out of 100,000 to 200,000 eligible electors registered themselves. One result was that in a city predominantly Chinese only one Chinese was elected.

In his book on the administration of Malaya, Mr. S. W. Jones criticizes the Malayan Union in these words:2

It had the aspect, whatever the underlying intention, of an attack on the Malays and seemed to be planning a Malaya

1 During the first ten months of 1951, certificates of citizenship were issued to 307,107 persons in the Federation. Of these 272,502 were Chinese, 26,199 Indians, Pakistanis, and Ceylonese, and 619 Malaysians.
2 S. W. Jones, C.M.G., Public Administration in Malaya, London Royal Institute of International Affairs, 1953, pp. 134-8.

CONSTITUTIONAL EXPERIMENT | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[57]
in which the Malay Rulers would suffer belittlement and the Malay people would exchange their favoured position as the people of the country for one in which they must either sink or swim.... But the principal cause of offence was the invention of the Malayan Union Citizenship which His Majesty’s Government intended to create by order in Council.... In this way the old political status of the Malays which preferred them above all others was to be destroyed, drowned in the deep waters of the new citizenship. Hitherto the British Government had been firm in its insistence that the Malay States formed the country of the Malays and had maintained that position, consciously, and subconsciously, and unconsciously, by preferential treatment. Its policy had been dictated by a conscientious regard for the binding quality of treaties, a recognition that its economic policies had. flooded the country with aliens (my italics, V.P.; see p. 38) and a realization that without protection Malaya would soon cease to be the country of the Malays. . . . The gravamen of the charge against His Majesty’s Government’s policy lay as much in this hasty, overriding treatment of complex problems as in behaviour which seemed to carry a threat of virtual annexation of the protected States. The plan to usurp the Ruler’s jurisdiction and to subordinate them firmly to the Governor and, in addition, to impose a revolutionary policy threatening the political existence of the Malays without opportunity for argument, was naturally shocking to a people who in seventy years of their relationship with the British Crown had never been given reason to fear such treatment.

The Malayan Union (Mr. Jones says later) had indeed contemplated an equality of citizenship as a basis for future self-rule, but the Federation which succeeded it not only restored the privileged position of the Malays but redeemed the Sultans from being mere Kathis (Muslim priests) and gave them a higher position in the constitution than they had ever enjoyed in the past. The Federal Agreement Mr. Jones regarded as ‘doing much to retrieve a dangerous situation and recover lost ground’. In 1953 the Federation (he says) was beginning ‘ to move smoothly towards fulfilment’.

This reference to ‘smooth movement towards fulfilment’ had reference, no doubt, to the changes in the Federal Agreement

CONSTITUTIONAL EXPERIMENT | MALAYA : Communist or Free?
[58]
made in 1952 and to the State Enactments defining the status of ‘Subject of the Ruler’. How far this belief was justified is discussed at length in Chapter 17, ‘Reforms Under General Templer’, and comment on the new legislation is reserved until then.

Quite apart from matters of citizenship, the Federal Constitution came in for some strong criticism in respect of its workableness. Whereas before World War II the High Commissioner through his Residents or Advisers exercised a considerable degree of control, the Federal Agreement substituted for these officials ‘British Advisers’ whose functions were ‘advisory’ in the literal sense. The political power in each State was in the hands of the Ruler and the Mentri Besar (or Chief Minister). When the Federation first came into being the Malays imagined that they would be able to carry on the business of government quite well on their own without any advice, with the result that the British Adviser often sat for days in his grandiose Residency (inherited from the old imperial days) with nothing to do but twiddle his thumbs. No official papers came his way, for the Mentri Besar did not choose to send him any, so that he was mostly in the dark as to what was happening in the administration. Later on, however, the Malays found themselves more and more in need of advice, so that the flow of papers began again and the British Advisers became influential in proportion to their character and abilities. At the same time, whereas the pre-war Resident or Adviser had direct control over the whole of the administrative machinery, the staff of the present British Adviser (apart from domestic servants) was one secretary (probably a European girl). Instead of handing over Malaya to the Malayans as the Union had contemplated, it had now handed it over to a handful of Mentris Besar. Lord Mancroft in February, 1952, said in the House of Lords, ‘To a stranger the constitution of the Federation of Malaya looks as if it had been designed by Heath Robinson and W. S. Gilbert after a good dinner at the Savage Club.’1

1 See also How the Constitution Works, Kuala Lumpur, 1950.

MALAYA : Communist or Free? by Victor Purcell.
Published in 1954 by STANFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS

No comments:

Post a Comment